Named the Most Outstanding Swimmer at the 2025 Atlantic 10 Championships, Tyler won three individual A-10 titles, setting conference records in two events and five team records, including the 100 freestyle, 200 IM, and 100 backstroke. She swam NCAA b-cut times in two events, set a new George Mason record in the 200-yard freestyle, and helped the team break the program record in the 800-yard freestyle relay. Finishing the 2024–25 season with 19 individual top-three finishes, Tyler also earned a spot on the A-10 All-Academic team for the fourth consecutive year. She was named the 2025 Women's Team Dr. Pettrone Athlete of the Year at the Green & Gold Ceremony.
